MIST stress test: adding an image shifts about a fifth of VLM judge labels, regardless of what the image shows
The authors built MIST (the Misleading-Image Stress Test), 200 English sentences each containing a phrase readable either figuratively or literally and shown with an aligned image, a misleading image, or no image; across thirteen VLM judges an aligned image changed 20.5% of labels and a misleading one 19.4%, versus 11.6% when only the ignore-the-image instruction was deleted with the image left in place, and only 37% of the labels that differ between the two images moved toward the sense shown, while agreement with the human annotators was unchanged whether the image was absent, aligned, or misleading.